The Great Debate: Generic vs. Product-Specific Business Name

August 20, 2024

Naming your business is like laying the foundation of a house—it’s going to support everything you build, so it needs to be strong and carefully chosen. The big question: Should you go with a generic name or a product-specific one? Each has its pros and cons.

The Case for a Generic Business Name

Generic business names are like the chameleons of the branding world. They’re adaptable, broad, and give you room to stretch your wings. Think of names like Amazon, Apple, or Virgin—at first glance, they don’t say much about what the company sells, but that’s precisely the point.

Pros:

Flexibility: A generic name offers flexibility to expand your product line or services without being boxed in. Say you start out selling handmade soaps under a name like Clean Slate. Five years down the road, if you decide to dive into skincare or even candles, the name still fits. A generic name can grow with your business.

Brand Longevity: Trends come and go, and if your name is too specific, you may find yourself sounding outdated. A generic name gives you longevity. If Netflix had called itself DVD Rentals Unlimited back in the day, well, you get the picture.

Marketability: A broader name also makes it easier to position your brand across different markets. You don’t need to explain the leap from one product to another because your name is wide enough to encompass them all.

Cons:

Lack of Immediate Clarity: The downside of generic names is that they don’t tell potential customers what you actually do or sell. Unless you have a hefty marketing budget to educate people, they may be left guessing.

Brand Identity Challenges: Without a direct tie to your product, it may take more time and effort to build a unique brand identity. You’ll need to ensure that everything from your logo to your tagline clearly communicates who you are and what you do.

The Case for a Product-Specific Business Name

On the flip side, there’s something to be said about naming your business in a way that leaves zero room for confusion. Product-specific names are like those perfectly tailored suits—they fit right out of the box. Think of names like Burger King or PayPal. There’s no mystery about what these companies offer, which can be a major advantage.

Pros:

Instant Recognition: A product-specific name tells people exactly what you do the moment they hear it. If you name your business Green Thumb Gardening Supplies, no one’s going to ask if you sell bicycles. This clarity can make it easier for people to find you and remember you.

SEO-Friendly: If your business name is directly tied to your product or service, you have a built-in advantage when it comes to search engine optimization. A name like Bob’s Plumbing will likely rank better for plumbing-related searches than something more abstract like Riverstone Services.

Brand Trust: Being direct about your offering can foster trust. Customers tend to appreciate knowing exactly what they’re getting into. Plus, it positions you as a specialist in your field.

Cons:

Pigeonholing: The biggest drawback is that you’re locking yourself into a specific product or service. If you’re Joe’s Tacos, it’s going to feel weird if you decide to start selling burgers. A product-specific name can limit your ability to pivot or expand your business.

Lack of Creativity: Going for a product-specific name doesn’t leave much room for creative expression. It’s straight to the point, but that might make it harder to differentiate yourself from competitors with similar offerings. You don’t want to blend into a sea of product-specific names that all sound the same.

So, Which Should You Choose?

It all boils down to your vision for your business. If you’re laser-focused on one product or service and plan to dominate that niche, a product-specific name might serve you well. However, if you’re dreaming of world domination and plan to expand into different markets, a generic name gives you more breathing room.

Questions to Ask Yourself Before Deciding:

1. Where do I see my business in five years? If you can confidently answer this with the same product or service in mind, a specific name might work. But if there’s a chance you’ll evolve, think broader.

2. How much time and money can I invest in branding? Generic names often require more investment in branding to communicate your business's essence. If you have the resources, a generic name could be worth it. If not, specificity might be your friend.

3. Do I want to be seen as a specialist or a jack-of-all-trades? A specific name tells people you’re an expert in one area. A generic name says you’ve got your fingers in many pies. Which resonates more with you?

Conclusion

Ultimately, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. A generic name gives you the freedom to pivot, expand, and adapt over time, while a product-specific name offers clarity, SEO benefits, and niche expertise.

What matters most is that the name feels right to you, aligns with your long-term goals, and resonates with your target audience. Whether it’s broad and expansive or direct and to the point, your business name is the beginning of your story. Make sure it’s one you’ll want to tell for years to come.

More Thoughts

Packaging Design
Brands that Ace QR Codes – To Add Value and Be Helpful

Marketing
Brand Identity
The Better-For Movement: Here to Stay or Just a Trend?

Brand Identity
Design
Marketing
Packaging Design
Packaging Regulation Requirements for FMCG in New Zealand: What You Need to Know

Brand Identity
Marketing
Packaging Design
Don’t Be Clever, Be Clear: The Key to Effective Communication

Packaging Design
Design
Brand Identity
Colour Psychology in FMCG Packaging

Brand Identity
Design
Marketing
Packaging Design
Eyes Make The First Sale, Mouth Makes The Second